Friend's Pretty Mother – I
(m/f, i/r, n/c)
by
Black Demon
_______________________________________
Standard Disclaimer!
This is a fictional story intended for Adults only!
______________________________________________
************        ***********
Note:  The story below is a story in itself.  However, it is also a direct continuation
of the earlier story entitled:  Star Player - V
***********        ***********

Mrs. Natalie Stevens pondered the drastic change in her life that had first started just over a year ago.  Now things were even more complicated and there just didn't seem to be a way out.  If she wanted to preserve her marriage to her loving husband, she just had to give in to the blackmail threats being made upon her.  After having welcomed her son's friends into her home over the past years, always welcoming them into her home, she just could not believe what had occurred this past week.

Her mind drifted back to the weekend when Dave took Bryan on their father-son fishing trip, off to a cabin near the lake.  She remembered her exact thoughts that went through her mind that day, prior to them leaving for the lake.  Natalie always encouraged father-son outings, feeling it was good for both Dave and their son Bryan.  'After all, with Bryan now entering his teen years, he'd soon outgrow the father-son outings to be with the guys or even with girlfriends!  Hopefully, Dave would be able to help Bryan some as he matured into manhood!' she had pondered at the time.  'Gosh, even his good friends seem to be more matured at this point, especially when it came to girls!' she told herself.

That last comment took her thoughts back to the day earlier, when Byran had invited his good friends over for a swim in the pool.  Sam, Josh, and Tim had been friends with her son since grade school.  But it seemed that now they were maturing quite fast, maybe faster than they really should.  She was even a bit embarrassed with the compliments they paid her that day.  Never before had they made such compliments to her and she had been a bit stunned at first, then just wrote it off to the hormones in growing boys.

Bryan was helping his dad with getting the grill ready for the burgers while Natalie took a dip to cool off from the hot sun.  She and her husband swam with the boys many a time and thus she had not given it a second thought in doing so again.  In fact, when the boys first visited as youngsters, it was a rule that they not go into the pool till either she or Dave was there to watch them.  They were quite safety conscious when it came to having youngsters in the pool for fear of accidents.  Also, she was wearing a very conservative one-piece bathing suit at the moment.

Natalie remembered blushing when Tim, the shyest of Bryan's three friends, said to her "Wow, you sure have long sexy legs, Mrs. Stevens!"  Then Josh, the boldest of the group commented "I've never seen anyone that compares to you, Mrs. Stevens.  She remembered stammering out a "Th …..thank you, boys!"  She then thought 'Gosh, I never thought they'd think of me in such a way!  I just thought they were too young to notice me as a woman!'  She felt nervous when Sam said "He's right, Mrs. Stevens!  Far better than even what I've seen in Play …….I mean swimsuit magazines!"

That's when Josh said aloud "Aw, Sam, you meant to say Playboy, didn't you?  But he's right, Mrs. Stevens!  You look sexier than any of the women I've seen in Playboy!"  That was when Natalie could no longer reply, blushing in embarrassment, knowing that these youngsters were verbally expressing their assessment of her features to a magazine featuring nude women.  Still, she did feel honored that these young boys looked at her in comparable comparison to such sex symbols, causing her to clench her thighs at the thought.

The next day, with Bryan and Dave off on their way to the cabin, Natalie thought it'd be a perfect time to relax in the pool and get some quiet time to herself.  Putting on her yellow bikini, she then rolled her long blonde hair in a bun to keep it from getting wet.  Grabbing a large towel, she went out back to slip into the pool.  Slowly she made her way to the deep end of the pool, resting her elbows on the tile to let the rest of her body float about weightlessly.  She was just about to doze off when she heard the clamor of Bryan's friends at the back fence, calling out to her "Mrs. Stevens ………..Mrs. Stevens!"  She looked up to see them but before she could get a response out, they were climbing the fence, excitedly telling her "You won't believe what Josh claims he can do, Mrs. Stevens!  We're going to make Josh prove it!  It'll just take a few minutes in your pool, Mrs. Stevens!  Is that okay?"

Natalie had not wanted to be disturbed, especially by these three teens, even though they were her son's best friends.  Realizing that she had on her yellow bikini, she shivered in recalling the comments they had made the other day when she was in a very conservative swimsuit.  She was glad that she was in the water and hoped the distortion of the water would assist her in not turning on these young boys.  With the boys already in the yard, there was no way for her to refuse their request.  "Well …………….I guess its okay if it'll only take a few minutes!" she said hesitantly.

With the three boys slipping into the water, Natalie didn't know why but she felt very uncomfortable being alone in the pool with Bryan's three best friends.  Then she saw Josh, who had been facing her, sink below the water and then come up for air.  With a wide grin, Josh burst out with "Wow, Mrs. Stevens, you look so damned sexy in that yellow bikini.  Natalie could feel herself blush a deep red with that comment, just as the two other boys disappeared underwater for a look at her bikini clad body.  Both boys returned to the surface to confirm Josh's assessment, making her even more self-conscious.

"Mrs. Stevens, Josh claims that he held his breath for over two minutes when he went diving last year!" Tim said with excitement.  "Can you believe that, Mrs. Stevens?" asked Sam.  Then Josh chirped in "I tell you guys that it was high tide in the canal last year and I dove off our small boat to get some oysters.  I swear I was underwater each time for over two minutes.  Heck, once when I was underwater, I managed to shuck an oyster and eat it raw before coming up for air!"  That's when Sam, Tim, and even Mrs. Stevens laughed at what seemed like a preposterous feat for someone his age.

"Well, I guess I'm just going to have to prove it to all of you!"  Josh spoke up bravely.  "You guys told me that you'd each time me, so get your waterproof watches ready!  Mrs. Stevens, tell me if I accomplished everything that I claimed I did!"  Natalie was puzzled at that statement, assuming that he wanted her to time him also.  Josh took several deep breaths in preparation for his dive, then spoke "Okay, guys, like I told you earlier …..don't start until my head goes under the water!"

Natalie looked on as Josh took a deep breath as he prepared himself for his long dive underwater.  She didn't bring a watch with her to the pool so she would look at one of the other boys' watch when he began his descent.  As soon as Josh's head disappeared under the water, she saw sudden movement from the other two boys who had been treading water on either side of her.

Completely taken by surprise, each of her arms were in the grasp of Tim and Sam.  Before Natalie could utter out a cry, Tim had his hand clamped over her mouth and Sam undid the pin that held her hair up, causing her long blonde hair to fall about her shoulders.  The young teens were quite strong from their football training, pushing her back a bit until she was pinned against the wall at the deep end of the pool, her arm placed onto the tiled drainage funnel.

She tried to struggle but Natalie found herself helpless in the arms of these deceitful teens.  Then a shiver went through her body as she felt hands on her hips, hands that were undoing the ties to her yellow bikini bottom.  Seconds later, her yellow bikini bottom was floating a foot away from her face.  She shuddered when Tim exclaimed "Josh is sure making good time!  He's already shucked the oyster!  Let's see if he can really eat it all underwater!"

It was all happening so fast that Natalie did not understand just what Tim was referring to.  But when she felt Josh's hands trying to spread her thighs apart, she realized what the filthy little animal intended on doing to her.  Struggling with all her might, trying to break free, her body suddenly froze and visibly shuddered.  'Godddddd ………….oh, God ………..this can't be happening to me ………….they're Bryan's best friends!  This evil Josh is a little animal ……..he wants to ……….eat me!' her mind raced.

The shuddering of Mrs. Stevens sexy body was the signal for Tim to release his clamping hand from her mouth.  "Ohhhhhh ……….ahh ………ahhh ……..ahhhhh …….ohhhhhh!" came the moans from the now delirious woman.  "Christ …………Josh is really eating Mrs. Stevens' cunt!" Sam blurted out as he continued holding on to the shuddering beauty.  "Go, Josh, go ………………eat that oyster!" both Tim and Sam cheered in harmony.

"Ahhh …….…..ahhhhh ………..ahhhh ………….oh, God …………….I ……….I'm cummingggg!  Ahhhhhhhhh ……………ohhhhh, Godddddd ………….!" Natalie cried out as she lost total control of her now convulsing body.  Seconds later, Josh broke the water was a smirk on his face, licking his chops for the benefit of his buddies.  Running his tongue slowly across his upper lip, Josh told his buddies "That was the juiciest and sweetest oyster I've ever tasted!"

Natalie was totally delirious from the mind-shattering orgasm that had rocked her entire boy.  She was unaware of her yellow bikini top being undone, allowing Tim and Sam the freedom of caressing her sensitive pink nipples.  She seemed to be just floating along in outer space, her mind unable to focus on anything.  But actually, she was floating along the top of the water with the boys assisting her like a rescue attempt, taking her to the shallow end of the pool

When her feet touched the bottom of the shallow end of the pool, it was as if she had finally come down to earth.  She gave a horrified gasp at her realization of what had just taken place, struggling once again in the arms of the boys.  "How ……….how could you boys do such a horrible thing to me!  I ……….I thought you boys respected me!" she sobbed.  "You ……….you're nothing but filthy animals!  I'll going to report you and see that they put you all away!" Natalie sniffled.

"But, Mrs. Stevens, we do respect you!  We think so much of you!" said Tim.  "Yeah, Mrs. Stevens, every night in bed when we're jacking off!" Sam snickered.  "We've thought so much of you, Mrs. Stevens, that we all selected you to be the one to teach us what fucking is all about!" added Josh.

Hearing that, Natalie began to struggle with all her might.  "We don't think you're going to report us, Mrs. Stevens!  Not with the tape we have of you fucking 'The Stork'!" advised Josh.  Natalie's trashing ceased upon hearing that, realizing that the boys had uncovered her dreadful secret.  She felt that her world had come to an end now that her son's best friends were aware of it.

"Yeah, Mrs. Stevens, we talked to 'The Stork' the other day.  He tells us that it was less than 15 minutes after you met him when you jerked him off all over you in the kitchen!  Then, when we went over to my house, you let him fuck you right on the bed you share with Mr. Stevens!" Sam bravely challenged her.  "Does, Bryan or Mr. Stevens know about this, Mrs. Stevens?" asked a smirking Tim.  "Tell you what Mrs. Stevens, we won't say a word if you take us to your bedroom and teach us the 'facts of life'!" advised Josh.

Sobbing, trying to cover her nakedness with her arms, Natalie realized that she had no choice but to comply.  Slowly she got out of the pool and shamefully, while still dripping wet, led the way into the house and towards the master bedroom.  Once in the bedroom, Natalie slowly walked to lay down upon the bed, closing her eyes, not wanting to see her son's friends approach her with their manhood in their hands.  She wondered who would be the first to rape her, then she heard how the decision was being made as the boys took coins from the dresser.  They were flipping coins for the special honor of being the first of the group to become a man, with the 'odd' man winning that privilege.

Eyes tightly shut, Natalie tried to steel her body in preparation of what was to come.  She told her self to keep her body lifeless, to let the boys merely satisfy their lusty hormones, but that she would not respond at all.  "Yessssssss ……..!" she heard the excited yell from Sam, who apparently won the honor of becoming the first to be a man.  She shuddered and bit her lip upon feeling the young teen scrambling up onto the bed, pushing her thighs apart as he scooted into position.

"Ohhhh ………..owwwww!" Natalie yelped as the eager young teen quickly scooted up onto her sublime body and sought out his first taste of a woman's breast, slobbering upon her left breast then biting at her tender nipple.  Sam was eager to become a 'man', shuffling up further with cock in hand, searching for her golden treasure.  "Ohhhhh ………..!" she moaned as the anxious teen stuck his cock into her without any further preliminaries.

"Yes ………..yes ………….I got her ……………I'm in Mrs. Stevens!  God, she's fucking fantastic!  I'm a fucking 'man'!" young Sam exclaimed.  He began thrusting with all his might into one of his best friend's beautiful mother, fucking her with jackhammer speed.  Sam heard his buddies encouraging shouts "Go, Sam, go!  Give Bryan a little brother to play with!"  Hear that, along with the feel of beautiful Mrs. Stevens cunt now squeezing at his sensitive cock, young Sam groaned with pleasure.  "Oh, yes …….yes …………I'm cumming in Mrs. Stevens ………….yesssssss!" Sam stammered as he began spurting his hot cum into a woman for the very first time.

Natalie had kept still on the bed as she had planned but she could not help her cunt muscles from responding to the eager young teen.  She wanted to laugh when young Sam lost his load with just two squeezes with her contracting cunt muscles.  She was just beginning to react when the boy lost it all.  All of that had lasted for just under two minutes.  She felt hands grabbing Sam, pushing him over and she felt his cock slip out of her with a slight pop.  Then she heard Tim's "Yesssss" as he prevailed in the coin toss with Josh and felt him scrambling up onto the bed.

Although she was horrified at what was taking place, blackmailed by her son's friends, she could not blame the boys entirely.  Natalie realized that if she was a young teenage boy, inexperienced in sex and with the opportunity to take advantage of an attractive older woman, it was a forgone conclusion of the end result.  She willed herself to keep her body absolutely still but thought it'd be interesting to see how many squeezes of her cunt young boy could handle before losing control.

Feeling Tim's eager mouth upon her right breast, tonguing and teasing her stiffening nipple, Natalie bit down on her bottom lip to keep from showing any response.  Tears formed in her eyes with the humiliation of knowing that another of her son's friends was now about to satisfy his lust upon her body.  The teasing sensations of her sensitive nipple sent a shiver of pleasure throughout her body but she fought the urge of clutching the young teen to her.

Tim was anxious, loving the feel of Mrs. Stevens' beautiful breast, enjoying the feel of her pink nipple actually hardening in his sucking mouth.  But he was so hard, his young cock throbbing in anticipation of fucking a woman for the very first time.  'Oh, God, I gotta get it in right away or I'm going to cum all over her!' he told himself.  Grabbing his cock, he shuffled into position, then pushed forward into the beautiful Mrs. Stevens.

"Oh, yes ……….I'm in her guys ……………oh, God, it feels so good!" Tim exclaimed as he pumped slowly into the now sobbing beauty.  After a dozen strokes, he suddenly felt her cunt muscles clamp tightly around his boyhood cock, sending him immediately over the edge.  "Oh, God …………..she's squeezing me …………..ahhhhh …….ahhhhhh ………….cummingggg!" he cried out as his body shook and he began spurting his load.

 Josh had observed how Mrs. Stevens had been steeling herself, forcing her body to remain as still as possible, not wanting to show any emotion at all.  He wanted to make this beautiful woman respond to him again, like the way her legs had closed around his head as he ate her in the pool.  He grasped a collapsed Tim by the hip and pulled him over and off the sobbing Mrs. Stevens.  Then Josh, with the aid of a recovering Sam, turned Mrs. Stevens over onto her belly.

Pulling her up at the hips, Josh had the woman of his dreams on all fours, right on the bed that she shared with her husband.  He knew she would try to steel her body and merely let him have his way with her, just as she had done with Sam and Tim.  Reaching forward, he cupped her beautiful breasts and began caressing her, gently teasing her stiffening nipples with his thumbs.  With her nipples now aroused to stiffness from his touch, he heard her moan softly as she continued to fight the urge to respond.

Slowly, Josh let his hand move down to caress her trim belly, then over the outside of her soft creamy thighs.  Then, as his hands wandered to her inner thighs, he felt her body shiver and heard her start to pant for breath.  He knew he was now turning her on and he would be in for a real fucking treat.  Josh smiled as he heard her gasp loudly as his fingers made contact with her love slit, his middle finger slipping inside in search of her sensitive clit.

With one hand fingering the now swooning Mrs. Stevens, Josh's other hand was on his cock, attempting to get it into place.  "Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh …………….!" Josh hard her coo as he pushed his cockhead into her mushy slit.  He knew she was now turned on by his caresses and fingering of her twat.  Pushing his hips forward, his sliced through a woman's hot cunt for the very first time in his young life.  More so, he had her in heat, hearing her moan for him to take her.

"Ohhhhhhhhh ………………ohhhhhhhhhhhh! Natalie cooed, losing all willpower to refrain from showing any type of response.  "Ohhhhhhh, Josh ………….yes ………you've become a 'man' ……………..fuck me …………fuck me!"  she begged.  "Ohhhhhh, fuck me ……………..fuck me ……………..make me cum!  I need to cum!" she groaned as Josh began to hump into her.  Reaching forward, she grasped the bottom of the headboard, allowing her to push back as her young lover sliced his manhood into her.

"Ohhh, yes ………….Mrs. Stevens …………….I've been dreaming of you every night!  Ohhh, my dream has come trueeeee!  Ohhhh, I want to make you a little baby …….give Bryan a baby brother or sister!" Josh chanted as he humped in and out of her gripping snatch.  Then what he heard sent him over the edge, hearing the beautiful Mrs. Stevens respond to him "Oh, yes, Josh …………..fuck me ……………give me a little baby ……….ohhhhhh, I'm cummingggggg …………shoot it in me!"  And Josh did just that, achieving his very first cum deep in a woman womb, adding his seed to her fertile womb.

Collapsing forward onto the bed, Natalie sniffled back tears of shame, realizing just how she had responded.  'Why did I have to respond to him in such a way!  Just like a slut in heat!  Begging Bryan's good friend to fuck me ………..to make his baby in me!' she told herself.  Feeling the young teen's body still upon her, still connected to her in a way only a husband and wife should be connected, she clenched her cunt muscles around the still oozing young cock.

Then all four occupants on the Steven's marital bed looked towards the doorway upon hearing loud clapping in applause.  "Well, 'boys' ……..I mean 'men', that was a fucking fantastic performance!" 'The Stork' congratulated them.  He began to get out of his t-shirt and shorts and announced "Now it's time for me to show you how a 'real' man treats a beautiful woman like this!  Wait till you hear I make her scream when she gets a treat of some black meat!"

The young teens got to observe their eighteen year old high school hero in action as he indeed was true to his word, making Mrs. Stevens scream and squeal with pleasure when he fucked her with his lengthy black cock.  They had seen it on the tape but in real life it was so much more exciting to see the trim white arms and legs of the beautiful Mrs. Stevens embracing the ebony body of the high school football star.  They observed how wild and wanton she became, begging for 'The Stork' to stick her with his big black dick.

After getting his rocks off, 'The Stork' played traffic cop, first directing young Sam to get on his back to let Mrs. Stevens impale herself on his rising cock.  Then he had Josh on his knees above Sam's head so he could get his first blowjob.  Of course, Tim would be the first of the group to sample Mrs. Stevens' beautiful tight ass.

As the young teens rested a bit, 'The Stork' had revived to again give the beautiful woman the long black cock that she craved.  Once he had brought her to another wild orgasm as he unloaded his love juices into her, he again directed traffic so each of the teens would get a different piece of the lovely woman.

At mid-afternoon of the next day, Natalie looked about the house to see that everything was in order, now that her visitors had left after she had prepared them sandwiches for lunch.  She was quite tired, dozing very briefly between the frequent bouts of lovemaking.  After the young teens had her in each of the three positions, they had taken time out to eat the pizza that had been ordered for their dinner.  Then, the teens wanted private times with her, wanting to now make love to her in private.  She had enjoyed this too, feeling free to let herself go without anyone else looking on at her slutty behavior.

Having stripped off the well-stained bedspread and sheets, she remade the bed that she and Dave would be sharing that evening.  Then to clean up the kitchen and wash all the dirty dishes that the five of them had used.  In cleaning up the den, where three of them watched television while waiting his turn to join her in the bedroom, she looked at the mess and commented to herself 'What a mess!  Typical teenagers!  Empty pop cans and crumbs all over the place!'

Natalie took a long soothing shower, enjoying the feel of the warm water, letting her hands wander about her body in remembrance of how each of the boys had intimately touched her.  She also put her head under the shower, needing to wash her hair of all the telltale evidence as she thought back to the final event that took place right after lunch.

That final event would not be one she would easily forget.  On her bed, while she had her back to 'The Stork' and impaled on his thick black cock, the anxious young teens also wanted to get into the act.  The anxious teens had gotten onto the bed and stood on it facing her.  She was then fed Tim's young cock while her hands were placed upon Josh's and Sam's cocks to jerk off.  Those two cocks in her hands had exploded all its hot juices into the silky strands of her long blonde hair.

Donning on a pair off shorts and a blouse, she surveyed her home once again, now satisfied that she had removed any telltale evidence of having visitors over the night.  Upon Dave and Bryan's arrival home, she eagerly greeted them and inquired about their fishing trip.

In the kitchen, while making some cold drinks for Dave and Bryan, she heard her husband calling to her from the backyard.  She shivered and her heart sank when she heard "Honey, what's your yellow bikini doing floating in the pool?"  Looking out, she saw Dave holding up the two yellow garment strips in his hands.  Going out to retrieve her bikini, she blushed and lied "I'm sorry honey!  I was relaxing in the pool yesterday and with no one around, I thought I'd be wicked and swim in the nude.  I got distracted and taken away to the bedroom from the pool area, completely forgetting about my bikini!"  Little did her husband know just how true that last statement was.

A couple of months later, at the dinner table, Bryan commented "Gosh, it seems that its so difficult for all the guys to get together at the same time these days.  Something's always coming up these days and one of the guys always has to cancel out for one reason or another!"  Dave just laughed and commented "Well, guess everyone's getting busier and busier with this being the teenage years.  Maybe they're meeting a girl on the side and just don't want you to know about it!"

Natalie just continued eating, not adding anything to the conversation.  Taking a deep swallow upon hearing her husband's last comment, she couldn't tell Bryan just how true it was.  When one of his good friends canceled out at the last moment, it was because it was his turn to perfect his manly status.  The two others who did show up were to keep Bryan away from his home in order for her to entertain his other friend in the privacy of her bedroom.

It had been nine months since that eventful day with Bryan's friends and 'The Stork'.  Now Natalie lay in the hospital bed, letting her newborn baby boy suck on her swollen breast for his feeding.  'Thank God the baby's white!  I just wonder which of Bryan's three friends is the father of young little Tyler here?' she pondered.  'Thank goodness little Tyler was under six pounds!  It'll certainly be easier to convince Dave that the baby was a month premature.

Once she had discovered her pregnancy, Natalie was of course worried that 'The Stork' was the potential father of the baby.  It would be fine if one of Bryan's friends had been the one to knock her up, but a little black baby certainly would not do.  She did not believe in abortions so Natalie pondered long and hard to find a possible solution to her problem.  To do so, she had worn outfits that would not show her bulging belly it its full extent, allowing her to convince Dave that her pregnancy and due date was a month further on.

Fortunately, her best friend from the sorority at college was living in another town a few hundred miles away.  She and Julie had been roommates at the sorority house for the last two years at college and had been inseparable, rooming together after college until Julie got married.  Julie had a bit of a wild streak in her and Natalie had often saved her good friend from some embarrassing situations, like when she was dating her boyfriend and now current husband.

She laughed thinking back to that time, Julie had just gotten engaged to Ryan, who had been off on job interviews.  Ryan was supposed to return the next day but managed to get in early and dropped in unexpectedly.  Upon answering the door and seeing Ryan, Natalie had thought quickly and advised him that Julie had called her and advised she had to work quite late.  In truth, Julie was right upstairs in her bedroom but she was not alone.  Julie still had a crush on her old boyfriend and when she bumped into him that day, one thing led to another.

When Julie had given birth to her first little one, a baby boy that was named Jimmy, Natalie suspected that Ryan had not fathered the baby.  Not hiding any secrets, Julie confided in her, advising that indeed her old boyfriend had knocked her up on that night when Natalie had saved her from being discovered by Ryan.  Thus, Julie was more than willing to assist Natalie in any way possible.

With the concocted story that Julie was in need great need of assistance with her sitter taking ill seriously, Natalie volunteered to go over hand help her good friend.  After all, Natalie was now on maternity leave and wasn't expecting to give birth for another month.  Julie had set things up with her doctor to see Natalie and to eventually handle the delivery of the baby.

Preliminary steps were taken for a couple to adopt the baby if Natalie so desired.  That young black couple was looking for a baby of black descent and if Natalie had been knocked up by 'The Stork', they would be taking a newborn home with them.  If such occurred, Natalie would simply tell Dave that she had complications and had to be rushed to the hospital but the baby had not survived.  With all bases covered, Natalie had set off to give birth in the town where Julie resided.

Dave Stevens took the call from Julie that his lovely wife had a fall at the home and that had set things in motion, causing the baby to come prematurely.  He was quite relieved that both his wife and baby were doing fine.  He was now the proud father of a little baby boy.  He packed his bags to make the long drive to pick up his wife and baby boy from the hospital.

Upon the Stevens' arrival home, along with their new baby boy, Bryan showed his parents the gift that his buddies had bought when they heard he was going to be a big brother.  Dave and Bryan were surprised that the three young teens had bought such an expensive gift since they only had part-time summer jobs to earn money.  It was a nice car seat for the little baby, a rather expensive one, decorated with a big blue bow.  But the young teens were only too happy to get such a gift for the new baby boy, after all, one of them were the baby's 'real' father!

A week later, with Mr. Stevens back to work and Bryan remaining after school for a science project, his three good buddies went to visit his little Tyler for the first time.  Each possible father got a chance to hold and cuddle little Tyler.  While one was cradling and feeding the baby with his formula, the other two got to taste the natural formula that Tyler was normally fed, each sucking hungrily on a pink nipple that little Tyler nursed upon.

During her days at home, when young Tyler was asleep, Natalie would go through the baby pictures that Tim, Sam, and Josh had dropped off for her to look at.  Then she found what she was looking for.  In the batch of Josh's baby pictures, she found a picture that  reflected the spitting image of little Tyler.
 

End of Story.